Is it time to change mechanics?

Nov 26, 2023

One in four drivers have changed mechanics in the last five years. When should you make the call?

Wait, what did you just say? Fire my mechanic? With a major shortage of skilled technicians across the country? With popular shops booking weeks in advance? Why would I want to fire my mechanic?

Consumers Report recently reported that almost 25 per cent of survey respondents reported that in the last five years, they’d had a vehicle repaired at a shop they no longer use; that they made the switch to another tech.

The industry has changed. Experienced technicians are aging and departing the trade, and the number of younger people entering as apprentices is at an all-time low. But let's look at the top reasons customers break their bonds with their service providers and what you might be able to do to keep those ties.

As you might suspect (but not always correctly), dealerships receive this complaint more than independents or automotive repair chains. Consumer legislation across the country requires detailed estimates for auto repairs and maintenance, but before giving the okay on a higher-priced job, ask if there are any options to reduce the costs. Are there remanufactured or other brands of quality parts that are cheaper? Can a used part be obtained? Can some of the work be put off into the future?

The responses you get to these questions and the way they’re handled will speak volumes as to whether or not it's time to cut the relationship. But be warned, prices have simply gone up. The automotive industry has felt the last two years’ inflation just as any other sector, and in addition to increased supply costs, car and parts manufacturers have faced broken supply chains and a global shortage of both computer chips and skilled labour. What might be extremely helpful is to find someone with sufficient experience to offer an accurate sounding board and review some of your previous repair bills, or in a pinch, a current estimate awaiting approval. You can ask family members if you’re lucky enough to be related to a technician or shop manager, but if you’re asking a friend or new acquaintance you might need to be more generous. An occasional bottle of refreshment or other casual gifts will cost far less than the dollars you stand to save.

It's also important to remember that some of the higher prices you face might be a result of your choice of vehicle. Some European imports, for example, can be competitively priced to buy or lease, but not to repair.

It can happen to anybody once, right? Check-engine light repairs lead this list, and for no small wonder. For every one of the dozens of trouble-codes that can trigger that dreaded dash icon, techs must dig through pages of diagnostics and many different causes. As a result, anyone from a first-year apprentice to a seasoned veteran can easily make a mistake from time to time. Like handling high prices, the response you get when you have to bring your ride back for the same concern will tell you whether your shop is worth keeping or in need of a divorce from your wallet.

Getting in touch with the shop as soon as possible is important; leaving something for weeks or even months before reporting it doesn't help your case or a shop's trust in your intentions. There should be some concerted effort from the shop to get a returning problem corrected. This may take a little longer than a single-day visit, and might involve a road-test ride-along with the technician, such as in cases of intermittent noises or drivability concerns.

You have the right to ask how a shop justified charging you for the first repair and if it was totally necessary. Don't expect full refunds or a free repeat repair, but the shop should recognize your value as a customer and treat you fairly, but this means fairness on both sides of the equation.

Some drivers who’ve been hit with multiple ‘check-engine light’ repairs have purchased a cheap code reader to let them know which code caused the first visit and why the light came on again. If it was the same code, it lends credence to the argument that the first attempt was a failure, but not always. I’ve lost track of the number of times I’ve read the phrase ‘replace with a known good unit’ as part of a diagnostic tree from the factory. This refers to the manufacturer's instructions to a tech to replace part X before proceeding with the next step in the process. Many times this involves electronic components which can't be returned once they’re installed.

This is number three on the Consumer's Report list of gripes that caused a break-up. Sometimes it's due to using cheaper replacement parts such as brake linings or tires. If you shop is constantly doing this to keep prices down without informing their clients, they’re not really doing them any favours. Paying twice for a cheaper brake job, for example, will end up costing more dollars and time than getting a quality solution in the first place. Just be aware that if you requested a lower-priced option, be aware that you usually get what you ask and pay for. This is when it pays to be up front with your shop about your expected longevity, and about how you actually use your vehicle. Shop technicians always get a chuckle out of someone who wants a slap-dash cheap job because they’re trading the auto in next week, only to be back a year later with the same ride, griping about how their choice didn't last as long as they’d hoped.

Brian Turner is still kicking and doing his best to put over 4 decades of frontline parts and service experience to work helping you understand not only how your vehicle works, but how to get the best deals when getting it repaired or maintained. He started with us at the Ottawa Citizen and hasn't looked back. He survived rooming with David Booth during his university days and we all admire him for that.

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

To contribute to the conversation, you need to be logged in. If you are not yet registered, create your account now - it's FREE.

5 Affordable EVs

Small trucks

Popular Crossover SUVs

Practical 3-row SUVs

Minivans for the whole family

Compact Cars

Luxury SUVs

Affordable AWD SUVs

Sign up to receive Driving.ca's Blind-Spot Monitor newsletter on Wednesdays and Saturdays

A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder.

The next issue of Driving.ca's Blind-Spot Monitor will soon be in your inbox.

We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again